Welcome to Chicago Community Kollel

Welcome to Chicago Community Kollel

Interactive Parenting Forum featuring
world renown Rabbi Yakov Horowitz

The parenting forum is dedicated this year

to the memory of Mrs. Gertrude Walder a"h


Negotiating With Our Teenager  

(Part One – Understanding the Dynamics of “The Deal”) 

Dear Readers: 

After a four-month hiatus, it is my pleasure to resume our weekly Q&A columns. Please participate by suggesting responses or by submitting questions of your own. 

A new question will be posted on Wednesday and I will respond to it the following Wednesday.  

Yakov Horowitz

Dear Rabbi Horowitz:

Our eldest child is in tenth grade at a local Bais Yaakov. She is doing well in school and is generally well behaved at home. However, over the past year or so, everything we tell her or ask her becomes a full-scale negotiating session. It doesn’t make a difference what the issue is – curfew, when to do her homework, when to clean her room, on and on. It is draining our energy and eroding our relationship with her.

Here are our questions:

  1. Is this normal?
  2. Isn’t it disrespectful for children to challenge their parents like this? Neither of us think we did this to our parents.
  3. Do you have any practical suggestions for us?

Names Withheld 


Rabbi Horowitz Responds

Nowadays, we keep hearing (appropriately so, I might add) that kids need healthy self-esteem. Well, I think that with the incredibly complex and challenging job we face, parents need to nourish their self-esteem as well.

With that in mind, I will share with you a short phrase that I tell people whenever this issue of negotiating with kids comes up in the question-and-answer segment of a parenting lecture:

“Only The Boss Negotiates.”

Think about it. When you are attempting to secure a pay raise at work, the only one that you approach is your boss or supervisor. Why? Because no one else in the hierarchy of the business has the authority to grant you additional compensation for your work aside from him (or her). 

So, in a roundabout manner, whenever your teenage daughter negotiates with you, she is acknowledging your authority in a very profound, albeit indirect, way. It’s almost as if she approached you and said the following things in sequence (all things in parentheses are unspoken sentiments):

  1. (I know that I need to listen to you because you are my parent)
  2. (If you refuse my request, I will have no choice but to accept your decision)
  3. (Now that we got that out of the way); “Can I please stay out until 11:00 p.m. instead of 10:30?”

Now; doesn’t that sound better?

While we are in the parental self-esteem-building mode, please consider the fact that it is also a compliment to the two of you that the lines of communication are open between you and your teen. Trust me; that’s not always the case. In fact, when parents approach me and tell me that their teens are completely ignoring their house rules, I almost always send them for professional counseling as that is a clear sign that there is a complete breakdown in the ‘chain of authority’ at home. Reclaiming that takes wisdom, time, patience – and the willingness to change.

This ‘self-esteem-for-parents thing’ is very important since you will be in the best position to effectively parent your child when you are confident, comfortable, and in control. That means speaking calmly, not lashing out verbally, and developing an aura of tranquility. If I can get back to the analogy of your boss at work for a moment, think of how your respect for your boss would diminish if he yelled at or refused to listen to subordinates when they discuss things with him. You would correctly feel that he is not in control of things. So; having the self-confidence to feel in charge and in control of your household will position you to effectively parent your teenage daughter when she ‘negotiates’ with you.

Now, to your first two questions:

1)      Is this normal?

Most certainly. Kids have been doing this forever. The tone may have changed over the years, due to a number of societal changes (explaining the reasons for this is beyond the scope of this column), but kids have always tried to negotiate with their parents.

2)      Isn’t it disrespectful for children to challenge their parents like this? Neither of us think we did this to our parents.

Well, that depends on how the negotiating is done. It is not disrespectful for your child to ‘negotiate’ with you – provided that it is done in an atmosphere of neimus and derech eretz. Your task as a parent is to train your child to do so. Next week; I will share some practical tips to help you accomplish that goal.

As for whether or not you did this to your parents; why don’t you give them a call and ask them that question. Their answer may surprise you.  

© 2007 Rabbi Yakov Horowitz, all rights reserved


click here to subscribe to our weekly issues

Email us at cckollel@cckollel.org

Call the Chicago Community Kollel at 773-262-9400 or email us at cckollel@cckollel.org for further information.
6506 N. California Avenue Chicago, IL 60645
To be set up with a chavrusah/learning partner please contact:
Rabbi Avi Weinrib: aweinrib@cckollel.org
Rabbi Moshe Sternman: 773-262-9400